Sabrina Suluai-Mahuka Fights Lease Sale in American Samoa 2026

News Desk
Sabrina Suluai-Mahuka Fights Lease Sale in American 2026
Google Map,(AP Photo/Annika Hammerschlag)

Key Points

  • The Trump administration held the first deep-sea mining lease auction of its kind in United States waters on Thursday, November 19, 2026, offering two 20-year leases spanning millions of acres (approximately 31.5 million acres / 12.7 million hectares) of federal seafloor near American Samoa.
  • According to the Marine Minerals Administration, deep-sea mining startup Wetstone U.S. Ventures won both lease areas at the minimum bid of $3 million each ($6 million total) as the sole bidder to place bids despite two registered bidders attending the auction at the Ventura County Fire Department Headquarters in Southern California.
  • The leases allow Wetstone U.S. Ventures to conduct initial seafloor surveys to explore for minerals and prepare testing or mining plans, granting exclusive commercial mining rights only if approved through further environmental reviews.
  • The sale proceeded following President Donald Trump’s April 2025 executive order on deep-sea critical minerals—aimed at countering resource competition from China—and despite a Monday court ruling ordering the National Marine Fisheries Service to conduct a more thorough Endangered Species Act assessment after calling its prior review “cramped, expedited, informal.”
  • Three legal challenges target the leases, including litigation involving Earthjustice (representing Fa’asao Amerika Samoa and the Conservation Council of Hawaii), a lawsuit filed Wednesday by the Natural Resources Defense Council and Finafinau (founded by American Samoa resident Sabrina Suluai-Mahuka), and a suit by the Faleula o le Manu’atele council of local chiefs.
  • Industry figures—including National Ocean Industries Association President Erik Milito and Eco Minerals head Tony Romeo—weighed in on industry growth and expected legal pushback, while local residents and environmental advocates voiced strong opposition.

Pago Pago (Edition America) November 20, 2026 – The Trump administration on Thursday, November 19, 2026, conducted the first deep-sea mining lease sale in United States history, auctioning two 20-year leases across millions of acres of federal ocean floor near American Samoa to startup Wetstone U.S. Ventures for $3 million each. The sale followed President Donald Trump’s April 2025 directive to tap deep-ocean critical minerals to counter competition from China, even as three lawsuits and a federal court order questioning an Endangered Species Act review cast uncertainty over the leases. Local residents and environmental groups opposed the auction, while industry representatives pointed to long-term mineral potential and anticipated legal battles.

Who Won the Deep-Sea Mining Leases Near American Samoa and What Do They Allow?

According to the Marine Minerals Administration, as reported by The Associated Press, the two 20-year leases near American Samoa each sold for the minimum bid of $3 million to deep-sea mining startup Wetstone U.S. Ventures, bringing the total across both lease areas to $6 million.

Although two bidders participated in the auction—held at the Ventura County Fire Department Headquarters in Southern California, where a few dozen protesters gathered outside—Wetstone U.S. Ventures was the only bidder to submit bids. The Associated Press noted that Wetstone did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

The leases authorise Wetstone U.S. Ventures to begin initial surveys of the seafloor to search for minerals and develop testing or mining plans. Under the terms described by The Associated Press, the company holds the exclusive right to mine those areas commercially only if approved during subsequent environmental reviews.

How Did Local Residents and Advocates Respond to the Auction?

The sale went forward despite opposition from residents in American Samoa and three lawsuits seeking to block the leases.

In a statement Thursday, Sabrina Suluai-Mahuka, an American Samoa resident who has opposed the auction for more than a year, said: “We had hoped it would never come to this.”

How Could Court Rulings and Lawsuits Affect the Validity of the Leases?

Whether the leases survive legal scrutiny remains unresolved following a court ruling earlier in the week and multiple lawsuits challenging the sale.

On Monday, a court ordered the National Marine Fisheries Service to carry out a more thorough assessment of how potential mining activities could affect endangered species, concluding that the agency’s earlier “cramped, expedited, informal” review violated the Endangered Species Act.

In a statement reported by The Associated Press, the Marine Minerals Administration said it had addressed the court’s opinion by initiating consultation with the fisheries service on another environmental assessment, without cancelling or delaying Thursday’s auction.

What Are the Attorneys and Plaintiffs Saying in the Three Lawsuits?

Legal opponents contend that the auction proceeded without required environmental compliance or authority over waters near American Samoa:

  • Earthjustice: Deputy managing attorney David Henkin said Monday’s ruling rendered Thursday’s auction unlawful because the government was required to comply with the Endangered Species Act in order to issue the notice of sale. Earthjustice attorney Chris Eaton said in a statement: “We will use the full extent of the law to vigorously push for the leases to be voided.” The Associated Press noted that Earthjustice represents Fa’asao Amerika Samoa—a group dedicated to protecting the territory’s culture—and the Conservation Council of Hawaii in the suit.
  • NRDC and Finafinau: A separate lawsuit filed Wednesday by the Natural Resources Defense Council and Finafinau, an environmental group founded by Sabrina Suluai-Mahuka, similarly argues that the environmental review process was rushed and asks the court to strike down the leases.
  • Faleula o le Manu’atele: A third lawsuit, brought by Faleula o le Manu’atele, a council of local chiefs in American Samoa, challenges the federal government’s authority to auction waters near their islands.

Representatives and executives in the ocean minerals sector commented on the commercial outlook and the likelihood of prolonged litigation.

Tony Romeo, head of the deep-sea mining startup Eco Minerals, which did not take part in the auction, said any company entering deep-sea mining must be prepared for opposition from environmental groups. As reported by The Associated Press, Mr Romeo said: “If they can halt it through legal action, they will. We’ll see how it ultimately plays out.”

Erik Milito, president of the National Ocean Industries Association, said in a statement that he anticipates growing industry interest and investment over the coming years. As reported by The Associated Press, Mr Milito said: “Decades of environmental research and extensive assessments have helped lay the groundwork for responsible ocean mineral development.”

Background: Federal Deep-Sea Mineral Policy and Global Context

Worldwide, deep-sea mining remains at an experimental stage; while a small number of countries have permitted companies to begin exploring their waters for deep-sea minerals, no commercial deep-sea mining operations have started. In the United States, no lease for deep-sea minerals has been issued since a brief mining effort in California waters more than 60 years ago.

Federal renewed focus on ocean-floor minerals traces back to an April 2025 executive order in which President Donald Trump directed his administration to seek and responsibly develop critical minerals on the seabed both inside and outside U.S. borders. Beyond American Samoa, the Marine Minerals Administration is evaluating potential future seabed auctions near the Northern Mariana Islands, Virginia, and Alaska, while the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration is reviewing permit applications from companies seeking to mine in international waters.

  • Residents, Chiefs, and Cultural Organisations in American Samoa: Communities, local chiefs such as Faleula o le Manu’atele, and groups like Fa’asao Amerika Samoa and Finafinau face ongoing legal proceedings and environmental consultations regarding seabed activity near the territory, with outcomes hinging on federal court rulings and subsequent environmental reviews.
  • Wetstone U.S. Ventures and Ocean Mining Companies: Wetstone U.S. Ventures can proceed with initial exploratory surveys and planning under its 20-year leases, while companies across the sector—including Eco Minerals and members of the National Ocean Industries Association—face active litigation risk, additional environmental review requirements, and potential expansion of federal leasing elsewhere if courts uphold the framework.
  • Federal Agencies and Environmental Groups: The Marine Minerals Administration, the National Marine Fisheries Service, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, and environmental organisations such as Earthjustice and the Natural Resources Defense Council face continued legal and regulatory proceedings over Endangered Species Act compliance, environmental assessments, and authority over offshore areas.